Butler's Bay Teal Lake Cabin

Butler's Bay Teal Lake Cabin is located on the shores of one of the Hayward, Wisconsin Area's most popular Quiet Lakes.

1700 square foot ranch. 4 bedrooms, a king in the master, 2 queen bedrooms, and a bunk bedroom with 2 bunk beds. 3 sofa sleepers provide additional sleeping opportunities. A nice size kitchen, living room and family room. Large screen TV’s in the family room and master bedroom. A large deck off the back of the house overlooking a sheltered bay with a sand beach. The bay is shallow and perfect for kids. Great fishing right off the 2 docks. A play set for the kid is available too.

Well known for its fishing, Teal Lake, and adjoining Lost Land Lake, are designated "Quiet Lakes" and have a 10 mph speed limit making them ideal to explore by pontoon. There is ample parking for your trailers and lake maps provided showing some of the lake's fishing hot spots.

*We have been working with the Department of Health and have new cleaning standards and procedures for all our Beds. On each bed we will provide sheets, pillow and pillow case and blankets. You will need to bring your own towels and any soaps.

** Butler's Bay is pet friendly with a pet fee **

Vacation Rental Reviews

• Beautiful and Peaceful cabin on the Lake

  Stayed 4 days ending in August, 2023

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Linda F from FLORISSANT, MO recommends this vacation rental

  Loved our stay at this cozy house right on the lake. We stayed here in August with my parents my 2 kids and my husband and myself. The water on this lake was crystal clear, the weather perfect and my kiddos caught fish by the plenty.The house was absolutely the best. Cabin cozy but yet had all the amenities of modern day without sacrificing comfort. We came to visit the Apostle Islands (which were awesome) but would definitely come back just for another peaceful stay here! The hosts were quick to respond with any questions as well!

  • Manager Responded on 9/8/2023

    Wow! Thank you for the detailed review on your experience! We would love to have you visit again! I am thrilled the fish were biting and you enjoyed the lake and the cabin. We hope to see you back again soon.. :) Elizabeth

•  

• Camp Cuhel 23

  Stayed 7 days ending in August, 2023

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  RON C from LA CRESCENT, Minnesota recommends this vacation rental

  Wonderful family get-together

•  

• Another Wonderful Year

  Stayed 7 days ending in July, 2023

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Janet D from Menomonee Falls, WI recommends this vacation rental

  Our third year at Butler Bay did not disappoint in anyway! We enjoyed some upgrades as well as the usual comforts this cabin provides. Our family looks forward to returning.

  • Manager Responded on 7/19/2023

    Thank you so much for the wonderful review! I am happy to you enjoyed the updates! We look forward to seeing you back! Elizabeth

•  

• 3rd times a charm��

  Stayed 6 days ending in August, 2022

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Stacey H from Walker, IA recommends this vacation rental

  This was our family of 12’s 3rd summer at Butler’s Bay. We absolutely love this cabin. It has all the things you need, cooking & fun in the sun. Very spacious home. Close to town & we love the shopping there! Our children look forward to coming back each year. We have made so many wonderful memories here. I honestly cannot say enough good things about this place. Thank you for letting our family continue this Hayward tradition.

  • Manager Responded on 10/12/2022

    I am so thrilled to hear you enjoyed another summer at our cabin Butler's Bay... We look forward to seeing you back in the future! Elizabeth

•  

• Butler Bay

  Stayed 4 days ending in July, 2022

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  a guest from Burt, IA recommends this vacation rental

  Wonderful experience at Butler Bay. Cabin had great amenities in addition to comfortable beds. Would definitely to stay again!

  • Manager Responded on 7/19/2022

    I am happy to hear you found your stay a wonderful experience! We hope to see you back in the future! Elizabeth RRP

•  

• Excellent location and relaxation!

  Stayed 5 days ending in June, 2022

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Aaron S from Lena, Illinois recommends this vacation rental

  We spent 5 nights at Butler's Bay Teal Lake Cabin in late-June. What a beautiful place in a perfect, secluded bay. Great parking for our pontoon boat which allowed us to gather our gear, walk down to the lake, and hit the water.

  • Manager Responded on 7/11/2022

    Thank you for your feedback! I am happy you found our home to be perfect during your stay! Elizabeth RRP

•  

• Extended Family Getaway

  Stayed 4 days ending in June, 2022

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  a guest from Saint Peter, MN recommends this vacation rental

  Great experience at the rental property, it was super clean and had many supplies within it (kitchen, board games, movies, outdoor games, grill).

  • Manager Responded on 7/11/2022

    Thank you for reviewing our home Butler's Bay. I am happy you had a great experience and enjoyed the the things this home comes with! Elizabeth RRP

•  

• Quiet, relaxing and wonderful

  Stayed 7 days ending in August, 2021

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Kristen G from Franklin, WI recommends this vacation rental

  We had a wonderful time. The lake is beautiful and the bay provides a peaceful, quiet space to unwind - plus the view is amazing. The walk down to the lake is short with just a few steps. The sand frontage is shallow and would be great for little kids.
  
  Teal Lake is a quiet lake which means there are no jet skis or water skiing on the lake. It's perfect for fishing and swimming off the pontoon. We loved it!!
  
  For August rhe fishing was pretty good. We caught a 40 inch musky off the pier and across the lake we caught northern, bass and pan fish.
  
  The house was well stocked with dishes and games. Ths kitchen appliances are high quality. The house had plenty of space for the 6 of us to spread out. Loved having 1 sitting space with a TV and 1 without. The master suite is very nice with a gorgeous view of the lake. The kids loved the bunk beds. The other 2 rooms have queen beds and were a bit small, but since we just slept in there they were ok.
  
  Overall, a great place to stay.

  • Manager Responded on 8/23/2021

    Kristen, Thank you for taking the time to write a very detailed experience on your stay! I love hearing fun fishing stories guests share and its awesome you were able to experience catching a musky! I am thrilled to also hear our home was able to provide you with everything you needed for a perfect vacation. We hope to see you again soon. Elizabeth RRP

•  

• Butler Bay on Teal Lake Family Vacation

  Stayed 7 days ending in July, 2021

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Walter J from Howard, WI recommends this vacation rental

  The pictures don't do justice to how nice Butler Bay is. The house is wonderful. Changed some since the pictures. It is huge and nicely decorated. They also provide so much in the cooking area. We had 6 adults and 5 children and had space to spread out. There is a cabin next door but is owned by the the brother and his wife who were very nice and helpful. They left on Sunday leaving only us in the bay. The beach is far better then the pictures show. We saw lots of wild life. Everyone agreed that they'd come back again.

  • Manager Responded on 8/12/2021

    Hi Walter, Thank you for sharing this. Butler's Bay is truly a fantastic cabin. We are so glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to see you again! Elizabeth RRP

•  

• Relaxing getaway

  Stayed 3 days ending in September, 2020

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Elizabeth H from Carver, MN recommends this vacation rental

  It was very clean, and nice and relaxing! Very fun lake to fish on!

•  

• Wonderful!!

  Stayed 5 days ending in July, 2020

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Stacey H from Walker, IA recommends this vacation rental

  Our large family had the best time! Definitely off the beaten path, very long lane. We were the only ones in the area at the time of our stay. Very quiet and peaceful. The beach area was perfect for our kids and family to hang out and play. There is a big sand area to play in that isn't currently pictured. The dock also has a bench on it now and another add on which was great for the kids to fish off the end for blue gills. The fishing in the lake is pretty good once you figure out the spots. The house has a fully stocked kitchen. Everything one would need. The bedrooms were all good too, comfortable sleeping! Plenty of room for everyone to be together in the family rooms. The deck area was great too! Would definitely recommend for a family get a way!

•  

• Great place to stay

  Stayed 7 days ending in June, 2020

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  Cheri S from HARTLAND, WI recommends this vacation rental

  The cabin was beautiful and well taken care of. We had plenty of dishes and cooking items for our party of 6. The furniture and beds were all very comfortable. We were pleasantly surprised to have Wifi available and there is a phone in the cabin if you want to bring a calling card. The television in the back room was not working for us. I'm not sure what the problem was with that. There is no fish cleaning house on the property so you have to clean outside before the mosquitoes get you. Also there were geese at the shoreline so the beach area was full of goose excrement. The beach area is not great for swimming but we were not that interested in that. There is a brand new pier and bench at the end which my husband was happy to see. The area is peaceful and quiet. We would definitely stay here again.

•  

• Family VAC to Hayward to watch Lumberjack World Championship

  Stayed 4 days ending in July, 2018

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  David B from Eagan, MN recommends this vacation rental

  Location was excellent - most beautiful lake and island off the back - couldn't be more pretty. Just a bit far (almost 20 miles) out of Hayward) but standable. Cabin was in OK shape - needs some TLC (as in the couch cushioning is non-existent) and one of the beds didn't have a sheet put on. Garbage dumpster was overflowing and we actually did see a black bear on the drive out of Hayward - so we kept an eye on our grandkids. Communication with mgmt company could be a bit better - sent 2 emails with questions and left one voicemail and none were responded to. All in all we would stay again.

•  

• Hayward family vacation

  Stayed 4 days ending in July, 2018

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  a guest from Roscoe, IL recommends this vacation rental

  Birch lake Lodge is a great place to stay. Just a few steps down the yard n you are on the private dock. Teal lake is great for kayaking and there are state islands to explore. The cabin was clean and had everything we needed. The only issue was the dumpster was plum full and was beginning to smell.. luckily the smell didn't start til our lastnight. The dumpster is a short distance from the cabin, so for the smell to reach the had to be pretty bad,but with 100 degree weather n fish remains,that can be expected. Maybe a extra pick up during the hot hot weather.

•  

• Labor Day Quick Trip

  Stayed 3 days ending in September, 2017

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  a guest from Northbrook, IL recommends this vacation rental

  Delightful. The management company is very professional and responsive. Great service and good business. We will be back.

  • Manager Responded on 9/28/2017

    Thank you for staying with us at Birch Bark Lodge in Northern WI! I hope to help with future stays!

•  

• Family Fishing and De-Stress

  Stayed 11 days ending in July, 2017

  • Services from rental manager
    
  • Cleanliness
    
  • Location
    
  • Property condition
    

  Overall satisfaction:

  a guest from Northbrook, IL recommends this vacation rental

  Location, perfect. Management company, professional and responsive. Peace and quiet, superb. Comfortable furniture...get some new couches and beds. I would visit again even if you didnt but you still should.

•