Book by phone: (715) 934-4622

Butler's Bay Cottage

Guest Rating:

Sleeps 6, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom. No pets allowed.

8554 W State Hwy 77 Hayward, Wisconsin 54843 United States

Butler's Bay Cottage on Teal Lake is a newly remodeled vacation rental located on the shores of one of the Hayward, Wisconsin Area's most popular "Quiet Lakes" offering a perfect relaxing Northwoods experience!

This cozy cottage has two bedrooms and one bathroom. One bedroom has a queen size bed, and one bedroom has two twin size beds, and a sofa sleeper. Step outside to take in beautiful views of Teal Lake and it is only steps away from the water to enjoy a picnic, swimming, or coffee near the lake. Bring your boat and dock it at the private dock and enjoy the beautiful views of the Northwoods. Outside you will have access to a grill, fire pit with lawn chairs and picnic table. Inside there are two sitting areas, dining room, and new washer and dryer. Butler's Bay Cottage has been updated with central air so you can cool off in the heat of the summer. If you need extra space, you can add on Butler's Bay Cabin next door for larger groups! Teal lake is well known for its fishing and its adjoining lake, Lost Land Lake.

Teal lake is a "quiet Lake" and has a 10-mph speed limit, making it ideal to explore by pontoon or by kayak and paddle boards that are available to rent. **Parking is limited**





Rooms and Amenities
Property Type Cottage
Unit Code H8C
Beds 1 queen bed, 2 twin beds, 2 sleeper sofas
Bathrooms 1 bathroom
Rooms Sleeps 6, This cottage has 2 sofa sleepers. One is a queen size sofa sleeper and one is a single size soffa sleeper
Pets No pets allowed.
Standard Amenities combination tub/shower, queen, sleep sofa /futon, toilet, twin/ single, forests, restaurants, zoo, Dining, Television, Smart TV, Air Conditioning, Clothes Dryer, Fireplace, Hair Dryer, Heating, Internet, Living Room, Washing Machine, Fire pit, Desk, Wifi, Coffee Maker, Dishes & Utensils, Dishwasher, Kitchen, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stove, Toaster, Dining Table, antiquing, bird watching, scenic drives, sight seeing, walking, ATM/bank, groceries, hospital, laundromat, medical services, Lake View, Lakefront, Rural, Water View, Waterfront, Kayak / Canoe, Outdoor Grill, Fenced Yard, fishing, freshwater fishing, swimming, children welcome, non smoking only, pets not allowed, flexible, necessary, Dining Area, Away From It All, Budget, Family, Tourist Attractions, Smoke detectors, Carbon monoxide detector, Fire extinguisher
Kitchen Full Kitchen, Refrigerator, Coffee Maker, Microwave, Toaster, Cookware, Dishwasher, Drip Coffee Maker
Living Ceiling Fans, Washer & Dryer, Fireplace, WiFi Internet, Wood Fireplace
Outdoor BBQ Grill, Gas Grill, Private Dock, Boat Rentals Available, Good Swimming, Picnic Table, Fire pit (firewood not provided), Kayaks
Entertainment Internet, Kayaks, Board games
Average Manager Rating (Based on 942 reviews)

Overall satisfaction

Services from rental manager
Average Vacation Rental Rating (Based on 2 reviews)

Overall satisfaction

Cleanliness

Location

Property condition
100% of our reviewers would recommend this vacation rental.

Vacation Rental Reviews

  • Awesome

    Stayed 3 days ending in June, 2025

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Dan G from PORTAGE, WI recommends this vacation rental

    I have come to the Clam Lake/Hayward area to fish twice a year with my family and friends and have stayed in numerous places. Dollar for dollar, I have to say this was the BEST!

    • Manager Responded on 6/12/2025

      Wow! Thank you for the nice review! I am thrilled you found Butler's Bay Cabin the best :) It was a pleasure to host you and your group. We hope to see you back again in the future :) Liz Recreational Rental Properties

  •  

  • Great Getaway

    Stayed 3 days ending in September, 2024

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from holmen, WI recommends this vacation rental

    Overall great spot for a weekend of fishing. The team was quick to respond to any questions we had. We would stay again!

    • Manager Responded on 9/27/2024

      Thank you very much for leaving a review on your experience at Butler's Bay Cottage. I am so happy you found it to be a great spot for fishing. It was a pleasure to have the opportunity to host you. We hope to see you back again soon :) Liz

  •  
Getting your rate Getting your rate...
1. Select Your Dates to Check Availability

Click calendar to set checkin/checkout dates. clear calendar

 Unavailable  Selected  Available  Checkin only  Checkout only
2. Review Dates and Rates

Select/Confirm the number of travelers to get a rate quote.

: :
Base Rent:
Promo Savings: Remove
Discounted Rent:
Fees & Taxes:*
Total Price:
:
:
What's this?

A promo code is for special discounts and may have been provided to you in either a newsletter, email or other correspondence from the manager or owner of this property.

*Click 'Continue Booking' to view details of fees & taxes

Seasonal Rental Rates for this Vacation Rental

Dates Daily Weekly Monthly Minimum Stay Checkin Restrictions
Dec 11, 2023-Dec 31, 2033 $220-$325 $1,540-$2,000 $6,600-$8,675 3 No restrictions

*Seasonal rates are estimates only. Actual rates may differ. Seasonal rates do not include fees or taxes.

To request information about booking this vacation rental, please fill out the form below.


Sorry, we encountered the following error(s):

  • Unable to process request.
loading Sending Email...
Your email has been sent successfully!

Sorry, we encountered the following error(s):

  • Unable to process request.
loading Sending Email...
Your email has been sent successfully!
46.06976,-91.11248

Recreational Rental Properties P.O. Box 1361 Hayward, WI 54843 (715) 934-4622 reservations@rrpwi.com

© 1999 - 2025 | Powered By Escapia Vacation Rental Software | Terms of Use

Logon